New York City — A compelling call to redefine and share the American Dream resonated from Cooper Union’s historic Great Hall today, as prominent philanthropist and tech entrepreneur Jeff Atwood joined Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman (Ret.) to address pressing issues of economic inequality and opportunity in the United States. The event, held in a venue renowned for hosting pivotal national dialogues, served as the platform for Atwood to unveil a significant philanthropic initiative aimed at fostering economic security through a Guaranteed Minimum Income (GMI) in underserved rural communities.
The discussion, framed by Atwood’s recent blog post, "Stay Gold, America," delved into the very essence of the American Dream, a concept first articulated by James Truslow Adams in 1931 amidst the throes of the Great Depression. Adams envisioned "a land in which life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone, with opportunity for each according to ability or achievement… not a dream of motor cars and high wages merely, but a dream of social order in which [everyone] shall be able to attain to the fullest stature of which they are innately capable, and be recognized by others for what they are, regardless of the fortuitous circumstances of birth or position." This foundational definition underscored the day’s discourse, emphasizing that the dream’s true value lies not in individual accumulation but in collective access and shared prosperity.
A Philanthropic Pledge: Immediate Action and Long-Term Vision
Atwood’s address underscored a profound realization, sparked by a high school theater performance of S.E. Hinton’s "The Outsiders": the American Dream is incomplete until it is shared. This conviction led to the "Pledge to Share the American Dream," a multi-faceted philanthropic commitment.
The immediate phase of the pledge involved substantial donations totaling $8 million. Eight diverse nonprofit organizations each received $1 million to address critical societal needs. These recipients include Team Rubicon, dedicated to disaster relief and veteran reintegration; Children’s Hunger Fund, combating child hunger globally; PEN America, championing free expression and literary arts; The Trevor Project, providing crisis intervention for LGBTQ youth; the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, advocating for civil rights; First Generation Investors, offering financial education to high school students; Global Refuge, assisting asylum seekers and refugees; and Planned Parenthood, providing essential reproductive healthcare services.
Beyond direct humanitarian aid, Atwood’s family reinforced America’s technical infrastructure with additional $1 million donations. Beneficiaries included Wikipedia, the Internet Archive, the Common Crawl Foundation, and Let’s Encrypt, alongside pioneering independent internet journalism and several open-source software projects. These contributions highlight a commitment to accessible information, digital preservation, and the fundamental digital commons that underpin modern society. Atwood urged all Americans to contribute, however they can, to organizations effectively helping those in need, emphasizing the collective responsibility in these short-term fixes.
However, Atwood stressed that immediate relief, while vital, is insufficient for systemic change. The "Pledge to Share the American Dream" demands a more ambitious, long-term commitment. Over the next five years, Atwood’s family has pledged half of their remaining wealth to foundational efforts designed to ensure equitable access to the American Dream for all citizens. This substantial commitment aims to plant a seed for changes that will take decades to fully mature, focusing on fundamental reforms rather than superficial adjustments.
The Genesis of an Idea: Confronting Economic Inequality
Atwood’s personal journey, marked by his parents’ rise from deep poverty in Mercer County, West Virginia, and Beaufort County, North Carolina, to the lower middle class in Virginia, informed his perspective. Despite family challenges, his parents’ unconditional love and support, coupled with access to quality public education and an affordable state university experience at the University of Virginia, provided the foundation for his own success. He highlighted the revolutionary ideals of Thomas Jefferson, a flawed figure yet author of "Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness"—words that define fundamental American values, even if imperfectly realized. For Atwood, the American Dream is not about isolated success but about collective connection and shared achievement.
A growing concern over wealth concentration in America, ignited by a 2012 video illustrating its extreme levels, propelled Atwood’s analysis. He drew stark parallels to the "First Gilded Age" of the late 1800s, a period named by historians referencing Mark Twain’s 1873 novel. This era was characterized by rapid industrialization, hazardous working conditions, and violent labor disputes like the Homestead Strike of 1892, where profit often superseded worker welfare.
The contemporary landscape, Atwood contended, has surpassed that historical precedent. By January 2025, America entered what he termed "The Second Gilded Age," witnessing the greatest wealth concentration in its history. Data from 2021 indicated that the top 1% of households controlled 32% of all wealth, while the bottom 50% possessed a mere 2.6%. This disparity has only intensified in the intervening years, creating a reality where the path to the American Dream is increasingly obstructed for many. Unaffordable education, inaccessible healthcare, and a lack of affordable housing trap individuals in cycles of debt, preventing them from building stable lives, pursuing careers, starting businesses, or even choosing where to raise families. For these Americans, the pursuit of happiness has become an endless, often fruitless, endeavor, representing a "profound betrayal of everything we ever dreamed about."
Guaranteed Minimum Income: A Historical Trajectory
To address this crisis of opportunity, Atwood, inspired by Natalie Foster, co-founder of the Economic Security Project, proposed focusing on a Guaranteed Minimum Income (GMI). This is not a novel concept but one deeply rooted in American thought and policy, offering a simpler, more scalable approach to economic insecurity with minimal bureaucracy.
The concept of a guaranteed income traces back to 1797, when Thomas Paine, in "Agrarian Justice," proposed a retirement pension funded by estate taxes, an early seed of the idea. This seed blossomed into tangible policy during the Great Depression, leading to the 1935 Social Security Act. This landmark legislation, a cornerstone of Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal, provided a guaranteed income for retirees, dramatically reducing senior poverty from 50% to 10% today.
In 1967, Martin Luther King Jr., in his seminal work "Where Do We Go From Here: Chaos or Community?", made a powerful moral case for a form of Universal Basic Income (UBI). King posited that economic insecurity was the root of all inequality, advocating for direct cash disbursements as the most effective means to combat poverty and achieve economic justice.
The principle continued to evolve into programs like the 1972 Supplemental Security Income (SSI), providing direct cash assistance to low-income elderly, blind, and disabled individuals, enabling them to cover essentials like food, housing, and medical expenses. As of January 2025, over 7.3 million Americans benefit from SSI. Further, the 1975 Tax Reduction Act established the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), a tax credit for working-class parents that encourages employment by boosting low incomes. In 2023, the EITC lifted approximately 6.4 million people, including 3.4 million children, out of poverty, making it the second most effective anti-poverty tool after Social Security, according to the Census Bureau.
More recently, in 2019, inspired directly by King’s vision, then-26-year-old Mayor Michael Tubbs launched the $3 million Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration (SEED). This pioneering initiative provided 125 residents in Stockton, California, with $500 per month in unconditional cash payments for two years. The program yielded compelling results, demonstrating improved financial stability, increased full-time employment rates, and enhanced overall well-being among recipients.
A Targeted Approach: Investing in Rural America
Atwood’s initiative will build upon this historical and evidentiary foundation. Partnering with GiveDirectly, a leader in GMI studies in the U.S., and OpenResearch, which completed the largest and most detailed GMI study in the country in 2023, the new initiative will launch GMI programs specifically in rural American communities.
The focus on rural areas is strategic and deeply personal for Atwood. Rural counties consistently exhibit higher poverty rates, fewer job opportunities, lower wages, and worse access to healthcare and education. Regions like Appalachia, the Mississippi Delta, and American Indian reservations have endured decades of entrenched poverty, with some counties, such as Oglala Lakota, SD (55.8% poverty rate), and McDowell, WV (37.6%), reaching extreme levels. This contrasts sharply with urban areas, where such high figures are rare. Data from the U.S. Census and USDA Economic Research Service clearly indicate that rural poverty is particularly difficult to escape.
Furthermore, rural areas offer smaller populations, which are ideal for initiating tightly controlled GMI studies. This approach allows for careful scaling, continuous improvement, and the robust collection of scientific data demonstrating GMI’s positive impact on individuals and communities. The initial plan targets counties with which Atwood has a personal connection, including Mercer County, West Virginia, and Beaufort County, North Carolina—areas that remain in poverty decades later.
The initiative will foster collaboration with existing local groups to coordinate opt-in GMI studies, providing outreach and mentorship to participants. A crucial component involves engaging veterans, leveraging their exceptional leadership skills and commitment to community service to support and execute GMI programs. Partnerships with established community organizations—churches, civic groups, community colleges, and local businesses—will integrate the GMI studies with existing support systems, ensuring continuity and relevance.
GiveDirectly and OpenResearch will lead the data collection, measuring impacts on employment, entrepreneurship, education, health, and community engagement. Regular interviews with participants will provide qualitative insights, ensuring the programs are responsive to the lived experiences of those they serve.
Beyond Individual Welfare: Economic Security as a Democratic Foundation
Atwood emphasized that economic security extends beyond individual well-being; it forms the bedrock of democracy. When people are freed from the constant burden of survival—securing food, healthcare, and housing—they gain "room to breathe." This breathing room translates into freedom: the freedom to raise children, to start businesses, to choose employment, to volunteer, and critically, "the freedom to vote." This initiative, he argued, transcends ideology, representing an investment in America’s future and a potential "greatest unlocking of human potential in our entire history." Empirical data from existing GMI studies consistently shows that even modest financial assistance is profoundly transformational for those in poverty, enabling them to move beyond mere survival and realize their inherent capabilities.
GMI is presented as a long-term investment in the America envisioned by the Declaration of Independence—a nation whose democratic ideals were designed to be malleable, adaptable, and perpetually improved.
The Legacy of Activism: Drawing Inspiration from Aaron Swartz
Atwood concluded his address by invoking the legacy of Aaron Swartz, a precocious programmer and activist who, like Atwood, used technology to advocate for open access to information. Swartz, a co-developer of RSS web feeds, co-founder of Reddit, and collaborator with Creative Commons, championed the universal accessibility of knowledge. His efforts included downloading public domain court documents from PACER, a government database that charged fees for information he believed should be free, and later, academic articles from JSTOR via MIT’s network, aiming to make taxpayer-funded research freely available.
What Swartz viewed as acts of academic freedom and information equality, authorities prosecuted as crimes. Facing aggressive felony charges carrying up to 35 years in prison, despite JSTOR declining to press charges and MIT calling for leniency, Swartz tragically took his own life at age 26. His death sparked widespread condemnation of prosecutorial overreach and ignited crucial debates about open access to information. Eight days later, a memorial service in the very same Great Hall at Cooper Union lauded Swartz for his unwavering commitment to the public good.
Atwood challenged the audience to embody Swartz’s spirit of activism, to be "brave" and "stand up for our defining American principles." He issued two calls to action: first, to contribute to organizations assisting those in need, and second, to join the movement for GMI by supporting research and initiatives.
With his family committing $50 million as a foundational seed, Atwood envisioned a collective effort that, decades from now, would be seen as a crucial step towards fulfilling America’s promise. He expressed a deep belief that everyone deserves a fair chance at "Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of The American Dream," urging a grand experiment to share this dream and ensure its vitality for generations to come.
About the Author
