In a significant move that sent ripples through the independent game development community, itch.io, a prominent open marketplace for indie games, announced on July 26th, 2025, that it had deindexed all adult NSFW (Not Safe For Work) content from its browse and search pages. This abrupt action, later detailed in subsequent updates on July 28th and July 31st, came as a direct response to intense scrutiny from the platform’s payment processors, primarily fueled by an advocacy campaign initiated by the organization Collective Shout. The decision underscores the immense power wielded by financial intermediaries over digital platforms and raises critical questions about content moderation, platform autonomy, and the future of user-generated content (UGC) marketplaces.
A Sudden Shift in Content Policy
The initial announcement from itch.io, published as a blog update, expressed regret for the sudden and disruptive nature of the change, acknowledging the frustration and confusion it caused among its vast community of creators and players. The core reason cited was existential: the platform’s ability to process payments, a function critical for every creator’s livelihood, was at risk. Without the capacity to facilitate transactions, itch.io, which prides itself on empowering independent developers, would cease to function effectively.
The catalyst for this crisis was traced back to a specific game titled No Mercy, which was briefly hosted on itch.io before being banned in April 2025. Following the game’s temporary presence, the Australian-based advocacy group Collective Shout launched a public campaign targeting both Steam and itch.io. The organization’s efforts focused on alerting and pressuring the payment processors used by these platforms, highlighting what it deemed objectionable content. For itch.io, a platform known for its permissive and open-ended approach to content submission, this external pressure translated into an immediate and urgent need to demonstrate compliance to its financial partners.
The Power of Payment Processors
The incident serves as a stark reminder of the often-unseen but undeniable influence that payment processing companies like PayPal and Stripe exert over digital commerce. For platforms that facilitate transactions, maintaining good standing with these providers is non-negotiable. Losing the ability to accept payments through major processors would cripple a marketplace, impacting not only the platform itself but also the thousands of creators who rely on it for their income. Itch.io’s management emphasized that this was a "time critical moment," necessitating rapid action to safeguard the platform’s core payment infrastructure. The speed of the situation meant that providing advance notice to creators, a standard practice for significant policy changes, was deemed unrealistic, leading to the abrupt implementation of the deindexing.
The deindexing measure is temporary, serving as an interim step while itch.io conducts a comprehensive audit of its content. This review aims to ensure the platform can meet the stringent requirements of its payment processors. Upon completion of the audit, new compliance measures are slated for introduction. These will specifically require creators of NSFW pages to confirm that their content adheres to the policies of the payment processors linked to their accounts, shifting a significant portion of the compliance burden directly onto the developers. Furthermore, the audit is expected to result in the permanent removal of some pages from itch.io, with affected account holders to be notified via email.
Chronology of Events and Escalation
The timeline of events highlights the rapid escalation of the situation:
- April 2025: The game No Mercy is temporarily available on itch.io before being banned. This incident draws the attention of Collective Shout.
- Pre-July 26, 2025: Collective Shout launches a campaign, directing concerns about content on itch.io (and Steam) to their respective payment processors.
- July 26, 2025: Itch.io announces the immediate "deindexing" of all adult NSFW content from its browse and search pages, citing pressure from payment processors.
- July 28, 2025: Itch.io publishes an "Addendum FAQ" to address numerous community concerns, providing more context on its actions and distinguishing its situation from Steam’s.
- July 31, 2025: Itch.io releases a further update titled "Reindexing adult NSFW content," signaling ongoing efforts and potential future steps toward re-integrating some content.
The Itch.io vs. Steam Dichotomy: Open Platform Challenges
One of the most frequently asked questions following itch.io’s initial announcement revolved around why its response appeared more drastic than Steam’s, which also faced scrutiny. Itch.io’s management provided a clear distinction, attributing the difference to the fundamental nature of their platforms. Steam operates as a "closed" platform, where every product page undergoes an approval process before it becomes visible in the store. This curated approach means Steam generally has a clearer understanding of the content it hosts and can take more targeted actions against specific pages deemed problematic.
In contrast, itch.io functions as an open, "User-Generated Content" (UGC) platform. With over 2 million product pages and minimal barriers to publishing, anyone can upload content at virtually any time. This open ecosystem, while fostering unparalleled creativity and accessibility for indie developers, presents significant challenges for content moderation. Itch.io explained that it could not rely on user-provided tags for accuracy, necessitating a broader, more comprehensive review rather than a targeted approach.
Moreover, itch.io emphasized its status as a "small company" in terms of both team size and transaction volume, especially when compared to industry giants like Valve (the company behind Steam). This smaller operational scale means itch.io possesses limited leverage to "push back" against demands from powerful payment processors. The potential loss of a major partner like PayPal or Stripe would have far-reaching consequences, potentially preventing the platform from sending payouts to a large segment of its creators. The actions taken, therefore, were framed as a necessary measure to protect the payment processing capabilities for the entire platform.
Uncertain Timelines and Proactive Measures
The situation remains fluid, with itch.io acknowledging that a fixed timeline for these changes cannot yet be provided. The platform is awaiting "final determinations" from its current payment processors, Stripe and PayPal. In the interim, itch.io is actively exploring alternatives, reaching out to other payment processors that might be more accommodating to the diverse range of content hosted on the site. As a direct consequence of the ongoing scrutiny, the ability to pay with Stripe for 18+ content has been suspended indefinitely. The immediate focus for itch.io’s team has shifted to content classification reviews and implementing stricter age-gating mechanisms across the platform.
Addressing Community Concerns: Library Access and Payouts
The deindexing sparked considerable anxiety among users regarding access to their purchased content. Itch.io clarified that pages classified as "deindexed" remain accessible to those who own them and have not been removed from personal libraries or collections. However, some pages have received a "content notice," indicating that itch.io can no longer support their business. For these specific pages, while downloadable files remain available in the user’s library (assuming the creator has not removed them), the platform’s support for their commercial activity has ceased. Itch.io strongly urged users claiming content removal from their libraries to contact support, as the implemented changes should not impact access to paid products.
In a proactive and consumer-friendly statement, itch.io reiterated its long-standing commitment to DRM-free content, encouraging users to download and back up their games. This recommendation implicitly empowers users to retain control over their digital purchases, safeguarding against any potential future content availability issues dictated by corporate policy changes.
Regarding payouts, a common concern arose about a rule in itch.io’s adult content policy that pertains to withholding payouts for "infringing accounts." Itch.io clarified that this rule primarily addresses "bad-actor" situations involving blatant terms-of-service violations, such as content featuring sexualized minors or real-life imagery, for which the platform has always maintained a zero-tolerance policy. In such cases, accounts are banned, payments refunded, and payouts withheld. However, the current situation is deemed a "special circumstance." Itch.io explicitly stated it has "no interest in withholding anyone’s earnings" and that the measures are solely aimed at preserving relationships with financial partners to ensure creators continue to receive their payments without interruption.
Evolving Adult Content Policy and Broader Implications
The platform’s adult content policy, previously more general, has been updated to include a specific list of prohibited themes commonly found in card processing networks’ acceptable use policies. While acknowledging the potential for semantic arguments and ambiguity within such a list, itch.io stated its intention was to provide more information rather than less, assisting creators in understanding the types of content under review. This addition reflects the direct influence of payment processor guidelines on platform-level content policies.
This incident on itch.io is not isolated but rather indicative of a broader trend where content platforms, especially those hosting user-generated content, find themselves increasingly caught between the demands of powerful financial intermediaries and the desires of their user base. The ongoing tension highlights the challenges of balancing an open, creator-friendly ecosystem with the stringent compliance requirements of the global financial system. For indie developers, particularly those operating in niche or adult content spaces, this means increased uncertainty, potential loss of discoverability, and the need to navigate a rapidly evolving landscape of platform policies and payment processor dictates.
The future of NSFW content on itch.io remains to be fully determined. The platform’s commitment to finding alternative payment solutions and refining its content classification system suggests a long-term strategy to re-integrate some forms of adult content, albeit under stricter guidelines. However, the immediate impact underscores the vulnerability of even well-established platforms to external pressures, reminding creators and consumers alike of the delicate ecosystem that underpins digital commerce and content distribution. Itch.io has appealed for patience and understanding from its community as it navigates this challenging and complex period, promising further updates as the situation evolves.
About the Author
